
The job is consistency
Somebody from the club has handed you a clipboard, pointed at a row of twelve cars, and walked away. You like cars. You are not sure you know enough about a 1966 Chevelle to tell its owner his is the fourth best one here.
You do not need to. A judge at a local show is not there to be a connoisseur; the job is to treat twelve cars the same way. The line every judging handout repeats, here from the rules a Navy recreation office gives its volunteer judges, is the whole job in two sentences: “Pay special attention to the way you judge the first car. Judge all other cars in that manner to maintain consistency.” If you are fair to the first car and identical to the rest, you have done it right, whatever you know about Chevelles.
Before the first car
Three things to get from the organizer, and if they cannot answer, ask until they can.
The sheet. What are you scoring, and out of how many? Published systems vary enormously. The Antique Automobile Club of America starts every car at 400 points and deducts. The Z Car Club Association’s judging manual scores engine, interior and exterior at 100 points each. A local Corvette club’s sheet we read totals 45: ten each for exterior, interior, engine, and wheels, five for cleanliness. At a local show yours will look like the last one, and that is plenty. Our judging sheet guide has a 50-point version.
Your classes. Which cars are yours, and who else is judging them? If you are paired, the convention is a veteran with a novice. Some clubs split by area instead, so that, in the ZCCA’s words, “the same person judges the same area within a particular class.”
Your conflicts. Tell the organizer now if a friend, a relative, or your own car is in a class you have been given. The AACA’s rule is the model: “A team member shall never judge in a class where he/she, a family member, or friend has a vehicle registered.” Swap classes with another judge. Nobody minds at 8 a.m.; everybody minds at the trophy table.
A routine per car
Take about five minutes a car. That is the figure in the Navy MWR judging rules (“Take approximately 5 minutes per vehicle”), and the AACA asks its teams to finish a vehicle “in 10 minutes or less”. Concours judges get fifteen or twenty. For a class of twelve, five minutes each is an hour, which is about as long as anyone stays sharp.
Walk the same loop every time:
- Ten feet back. Stance, panel alignment, the overall impression. Write that number first, before details talk you out of it.
- Paint and body, up close. Sight down each side for waves. Look at door gaps, chips, and badly touched-up chips, and at the edges of trim for overspray.
- Wheels and tires.
- Interior. Through the open door or window. Seats, carpet, dash, headliner.
- Engine bay. Cleanliness, wiring and hoses that look like they belong together, leaks.
Two rules of manners that are also in the rulebooks. “Do not touch the car without permission from the owner.” And look only as low as you can bend or squat; even the AACA, which judges chassis, tells its judges not to crawl completely under a vehicle. One more, which saves a lot of arguments on a gravel lot: “Dust from the show field should not be considered.”

What the numbers mean
The hardest part of a ten-point line is deciding what a six is. No rulebook we read defines it, so here are the anchors we would use, offered as ours and nobody’s standard. Ten is a car where you looked for a flaw and could not find one. Eight is excellent work with one or two things you had to hunt for. Six is a clean, honest car with flaws visible from where you are standing. Four has problems anyone would notice. You will rarely go lower at a show people paid to enter.
Use the whole range. A judge who scores every car between seven and nine has not judged anything; the class gets decided by rounding. And write a note beside any score below a seven. The Oldsmobile Club of America’s rules send an entire class back to be re-judged if the sheets come in with no comments, which tells you how much organizers value them when an owner asks why.
The traps
The first car sets your scale. If you give the first car a nine for paint and the fourth car is plainly better, you have nowhere to go. Walk the whole class once before you write a number.
Punishing a car you dislike. The Navy rules put it well: if a car should not win, “simply score so that they do not win, but don’t destroy the vehicle on the judging sheet.” The owner will see that sheet.
Brand loyalty. “Do not allow the marquee to bias your scoring.” You are judging the work, not deciding if you would own one.
Crowd noise. The car with the most people around it is the most popular car. That is a different award.
Talking to owners
The rulebooks disagree here, which means the organizer has to tell you which show this is. The AACA is strict: “Never engage in conversation with the owner of the vehicle being judged.” The Navy handout goes the other way: “Be polite; introduce yourself to the owner.” At a local show the friendly rule is the right one. Say hello, ask if you may look inside, and let them tell you one thing about the car.
What every rulebook agrees on is the score. “Never divulge a score to anyone for any reason.” Not to the owner, not to his friend, not as a hint. If an owner asks how he did, the answer is that results are announced at the awards.
Ties
You will get one, and you should know the show’s rule before you do. We expected the published rulebooks to name a tiebreaker category and they do not. The Mustang Club of America has its two head judges break every tie. A Corvette club sends a team back out to re-judge the tied cars. The town of Oxford, North Carolina’s rules say “Tie breakers will be made by the judges after a short evaluation and possible re-inspection.” And the Oldsmobile club, after checking that both cars run, gives the point to the entry driven the farthest, which is the most car-show answer imaginable.
The common thread is a second look by a second person. Never settle a tie by asking the two owners anything.

Your first class
Walk the row once without the clipboard. Then judge it in order, the same loop, five minutes each, a note under every low score, and hand the sheets in without telling anyone a number. If the show runs on Car Show HQ, your scoresheet is on your phone: you sign in by scanning the code on your judge card, your class list shows every score you have given line by line so a 62 and a 64 can be compared without opening either sheet, and nothing is public until the organizer finalizes. The judged scoring doc shows what you will see.
And when it is over, tell the organizer which line on the sheet you could not score consistently. That is how the sheet gets better for the next first-time judge.


