
Three ways to decide who wins
Every car show answers one question before any other: who decides the winners. There are three answers. The crowd votes, which is People’s Choice. The entrants vote for each other, which is participant judging. Or judges score each car against a sheet. Everything else about the day, from how many volunteers you need to when the trophies come out, follows from that choice, and most first-year shows make it by accident.
The format is a decision about who the show is for. It is not a software decision, and no sanctioning body publishes a rule for which format suits which show, so what follows is the published definitions, the documented ways each one goes wrong, and our judgment about where each fits.
People’s Choice
Ed Gilbertson of the International Chief Judge Advisory Group describes it plainly: “A very subjective way to determine award winners. It is usually done by issuing ballots to spectators. They mark their choice and submit for a count of all ballots.”
That subjectivity is the appeal. A People’s Choice show belongs to the town. Spectators walk the rows with a job to do, they look harder at the cars, they stay longer, and the winner is the car a few hundred people liked best, which is a perfectly good definition of winning at a charity show in a church parking lot.
It goes wrong the way Gilbertson says it does: it “is very open to bias due to friends voting for the cars of friends or deliberate efforts to swing votes to a particular car.” The entrant with forty relatives wins. You cannot remove that, but you can bound it: one vote per person per category, and voting only by people who are standing at the show. On Car Show HQ, spectators vote by scanning the code on a windshield card, and a location check keeps voting on the grounds. The spectator voting doc covers both.
Participant judging
Here the entrants vote for each other. Gilbertson again: “There are shows that actually choose class winners based on a vote of the other entrants in the class.” It is popular for a practical reason, which is that the voters are already there, they know cars, and you do not have to recruit a single judge. A car that wins a participant vote has been approved by the people who know how hard it was to build.
The failure is the club that arrives twenty cars deep. One Corvette owner described it on CorvetteForum in 2015: “One of the other clubs that attended had one person from their club fill out all of the ballots for their members soon after they got there and before registration closed, voting only for the club member’s cars. This club ended up taking home almost every award given.” Gilbertson names the quieter version of the same problem, that entrants may be “voting for the person rather than the car.”
Shows fight it with rules: no voting in your own class, one ballot handed to one driver at check-in, ballots that only open after registration closes. All of them help and none of them stops a determined club. If your field is one big club and a handful of independents, participant judging will produce a result the independents do not believe, and they will not come back.

Judged
Judges score each car against a published standard. The big clubs each have their own. The Antique Automobile Club of America starts every car at 400 points and deducts: its 2026 judging guidelines say “All vehicles are given 400 points at the start of the judging. Judges deduct points according to accepted AACA standards.” Carlisle Events’ Standard of Excellence scores out of 100. The ISCA judges show cars in five areas, from body and paint to undercarriage. And Goodguys, which gives out some of the best-known awards in the hobby, says it does not use a point system at all and picks by evaluation.
A judged result is the easiest one to defend, because you can show the sheet. It is also the most work. You need judges who are not entrants, a sheet, a briefing, and enough time per car, and judges bring their own problems: they know some marques better than others, and a class judged at nine in the morning gets a fresher eye than one judged at one in the afternoon. Our judging sheet guide covers the sheet and the briefing.
A local judged show does not need a 400-point system. Five lines and forty-five points will separate a class of ten cars.

Most good shows mix them
The three formats answer different questions, so plenty of shows ask more than one. The Port Townsend Kiwanis Classic Car Show in Washington lists peer awards by class, a People’s Choice, a Kids’ Choice, and a judged Best of Show, all at one event. The Arthritis Foundation’s charity auto show in Dublin, Ohio runs team judging for every class and adds People’s Choice honors on top. Carlisle keeps the two apart on purpose: cars in its judged program are not included in the showfield participant ballot.
The combination we would recommend to nearly any show over a hundred cars is judged classes plus one People’s Choice award. The judges give the builders a result they respect, and the crowd gets a ballot and a reason to walk every row.
How long the count takes
This is the part nobody budgets for. A show chairman on the British Car Forum described a 300-car show with about 36 classes: “We now use about 8 people who count in batches but it still takes about 1.5 hours.” That is twelve volunteer-hours spent in a tent while the entrants watch the sky and think about the drive home.
It does not have to be that. At the 2026 Labor Day Car Show in Fairfax, 3,574 spectator votes came in on phones across 407 cars, and results were final four minutes after voting closed, because a tally that happens as each vote is cast has nothing left to count at the end. Whatever format you choose, decide how the count happens before you decide anything else about the awards ceremony.
Picking yours
Our judgment, for what it is worth:
| Your show | Format we would pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Charity, church, school, or community show | People’s Choice | The crowd is the point, and you have no judges to recruit |
| Single-marque club show, members who know each other | Participant judging, with a no-own-class rule | The voters know the cars better than any outside judge |
| Mixed field with one dominant club | Judged, or People’s Choice | Participant voting will be decided by the biggest club |
| 100 cars and up, entrants who care about the result | Judged classes plus one People’s Choice | A defensible result and a ballot for the crowd |
| Concours or restoration-focused show | Judged, by points | The entrants came for the scoresheet |
| Weekly cruise-in or cars and coffee | None | Nobody came for a trophy |
Car Show HQ asks the same question in setup, in the same words: who decides the winners. Open show is the crowd, Closed show is the entrants, Judged show is judges with a scoresheet, and a judged show can still run a People’s Choice alongside. Write your answer down, tell entrants on the flyer which one it is, and do not change it on show morning because a club complained in the parking lot.


