
The short answer on a $25 entry
Stripe and Square keep about the same slice of a $25 entry when the payment runs through connected software, PayPal’s checkout button keeps a third of a dollar more, and on a small show that gap stops mattering. Across 75 cars, the spread between the cheapest and the dearest option comes to about $25. That’s one entry fee.
So pick on the rest: how fast the money reaches the bank, what a dispute costs you, whose Social Security number sits on the account, and whether you’ll take cards at the table. Every figure below comes from the provider’s own pricing or help pages as we read them on November 6, 2026, and they do change, so check before you print a budget.
What each one keeps
| How the payment is taken | Published rate | You keep on $25 | You keep on $20 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stripe, online | 2.9% + 30¢ | $23.97 | $19.12 |
| Square, through connected software | 2.9% + 30¢ | $23.97 | $19.12 |
| Square, its own link on the free plan | 3.3% + 30¢ | $23.87 | $19.04 |
| PayPal payment link, paid by card | 2.99% + 49¢ | $23.76 | $18.91 |
| PayPal Checkout button | 3.49% + 49¢ | $23.64 | $18.81 |
Rates: Stripe, Square’s fee page, Square’s developer pricing, PayPal.
Those two Square rows are the detail worth your attention. Square’s fee page lists 3.3% plus 30 cents for online sales on the free plan and, on a separate line, 2.9% plus 30 cents for its online API. Its developer pricing page puts the Checkout API in that second group. A link you make yourself in the Square dashboard costs four-tenths of a point more than the same sale made through registration software connected to your Square account. The fee line on your first real transaction will tell you which one you’re on.
PayPal’s flat 49 cents is what hurts at this price, since a fixed fee bites harder the smaller the sale. Across 200 entries at $25 you’d hand over about $205 to Stripe or on Square’s API line, $225 on Square’s own link, and $272.50 on PayPal’s checkout button.

Everything that isn’t the rate
| Square | Stripe | PayPal | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Money reaches your bank | Next business day for payments before 8 PM Eastern | 2 business days, after a first payout that takes 7 to 14 days | Sits in your PayPal balance, then 1 to 3 business days once you transfer it |
| Instant transfer | 1.95% | 1.5%, 50¢ minimum, not open to new accounts | 1.5%, 50¢ minimum |
| Dispute fee | None | $15, never returned, plus $15 to contest it (returned if you win) | $15 on checkout payments, waived if you win; $20 chargeback fee on direct card payments |
| Fee back on a refund | No | No | No |
| Tap in person, on $25 | 2.6% + 15¢, or 80¢ | 2.7% + 5¢, or 73¢ | 2.29% + 9¢, or 66¢ |
| Nonprofit rate | None | Only if 80% of volume is tax-deductible donations | 1.99% + 49¢ after approval |
Sources: Square on deposits, disputes and refunds; Stripe on payouts, disputes and refunds; PayPal on transfers and disputes.
Refunds and disputes on a club account
None of the three gives the processing fee back when you refund. If you cancel a 200-car show for weather and refund everybody, the $205 is gone. That belongs in the conversation about your rain policy, long before anyone looks at a radar.
Disputes are where the three really split, and Square is the kindest to a volunteer treasurer. A club with 200 entries won’t see many, but picture one: a spouse who doesn’t recognize a charge from a club name on the statement. On Square there’s no fee, and if you win you get the money and the processing fee back. On Stripe the $15 is gone the moment the dispute opens, win or lose, and arguing it costs a second $15 that you only recover by winning. Contest a $25 entry and lose, and that one chargeback has cost the club $55. PayPal sits between them, charging $15 on checkout payments and dropping it if the decision goes your way. PayPal’s separate $20 chargeback fee applies to cards not run through a PayPal account or guest checkout, and we couldn’t confirm on its pages whether that one comes back on a win.
Whichever you use, set the name on the statement to something a registrant will recognize. It’s the cheapest dispute prevention there is.
Whose name goes on the account
Treasurers change. Clubs forget that when they open a payment account.
Square’s activation asks for a Social Security or taxpayer number from a person, and says it “must be valid, even if you’re signing up as a business or organization.” PayPal’s nonprofit verification wants the club’s EIN plus a tax ID for an executive contact. Stripe asks about the business and your relationship to it. Every one of them ends up tied to a human being, so have that conversation at a board meeting, not the week registration opens, and use a shared club email address for the login so it can pass to the next treasurer. A treasurer’s personal PayPal holding the club’s entry fees is the arrangement we’d talk you out of, because when that person moves on, the history goes too.
Nonprofit rates
This is where a lot of 501(c)(3) clubs assume a discount they won’t get. Square publishes none. Stripe’s discount needs 80% of your volume to come from tax-deductible donations, and Stripe says it isn’t for accounts selling products or tickets, so a show funded by entry fees won’t qualify. PayPal is the one real option: a charity rate of 1.99% plus 49 cents, which would leave you $24.01 of a $25 entry. It takes an application and pre-approval, and PayPal says not all payment types qualify. We couldn’t confirm that entry fees do, so ask in writing, and budget at the normal rate until someone says yes.
Taking cards at the table
At the 2026 Labor Day Car Show in Fairfax, more than 200 of the 407 cars registered at the tent on show morning. If your show looks anything like that, the in-person line matters more than the online one, and on rate alone PayPal’s Zettle reader wins by 14 cents on a $25 tap. We still wouldn’t choose on 14 cents. Who’s running the table, how many readers you need, and whether one account can carry both online and in-person sales will matter more by 9 AM, and a club that’s already on Square gets both in one place with next-day deposits.

Which one we would pick
- A club taking walk-ups: Square. One account covers online and the tap at the table, deposits land the next business day, and a dispute costs you nothing extra. If you made us choose blind, this is the one.
- A club with no account and online entries only: Stripe, and open it early. A 7 to 14 day first payout is fine in March and miserable the week the trophy balance is due.
- A club already on PayPal for dues: stay put. Moving the treasurer’s whole routine to save $25 on a 75-car show is a bad trade, and it only starts to look different past a few hundred entries.
- A 501(c)(3): apply for PayPal’s charity rate and get the entry fee question answered first. If the answer is no, go back to the first two.
Where Car Show HQ comes in
We sell car show software, so weigh all of that accordingly. Car Show HQ connects to any of the three by sign-in, entry fees go straight to your own account, and we don’t add a fee of our own, so the processor’s cut in the table above is the whole cost. Square shows can also pair a Square Terminal reader with the check-in kiosk. Our registration uses Square’s Checkout API, which is the line Square’s developer page lists at 2.9% plus 30 cents.
Whichever provider you land on, register your own car first and pay the fee for real, then compare the fee line to this table before you open entries to anyone else. The payments doc covers who handles refunds and chargebacks, and if you’re still setting the price, start with how much to charge for entry.


